Borderline Personality Disorder

Borderline personality disorder (BPD, also called Emotionally Unstable PD) prototypic description:

Borderlines are terrified of being abandoned, which leads to intense relationships that often end in disappointment when they split on their favourite person. They are prone to self-damaging behaviours and self-harm and suicide attempts are common. They have a fragmented, unstable sense of self. They are often impulsive and prone to anger.

Features of BPD

  • Triggering Event(s): The expectation of meeting goals; maintaining close relationships; real or imagined abandonment
  • Behavioral Style: Self-damaging behaviours (self-harm, self-sabotage, suicidal ideation); aggression; achieve less than they could (e.g. in work or school); chronic insomnia & irregular circadian rhythms (“body clocks”); feel helpless & empty void
  • Interpersonal Style: “Paradoxical instability”; splitting (idealise & cling vs devalue & dismiss); sensitive to rejection; “abandonment depression” & separation anxiety; paradox between superficial yet quickly developed and intense relationships; “extraordinarily intolerant” of being alone
  • Cognitive Style: Inflexible (splitting) & impulsive; difficulty learning from the past; external loss of control leads them to blame others to avoid feeling powerless; emotions fluctuate between hope and despair; unstable self-image and fragmented sense of self; unable to tolerate frustration; brief psychotic episodes; dissociation; intense rage; difficulty focusing & processing information
  • Affective Style: Mood swings; inappropriately intense anger; feelings of emptiness, boredom, a “void”; emotional dysregulation
  • Temperament: Either passive (dependent subtype), hyperreactive (histrionic subtype), or irritable (passive-aggressive subtype)
  • Attachment Style: Disorganized
  • Parental Injunction: “If you grow up, bad things will happen to me [caregiver].”; Overprotective, demanding or inconsistent parenting
  • Self-View: “I don’t know who I am or where I’m going.”; identity problems involving gender, career, loyalties, and values; self-esteem fluctuates with emotions
  • World-View: Splits between people and the world as either all-good or all-bad, resulting in commitment issues
  • Maladaptive Schemas: Abandonment; defectiveness; abuse/mistrust; emotional deprivation; social isolation; insufficient self-control
  • Optimal Diagnostic Criterion: Frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment

Subtypes: Discouraged; Impulsive; Petulant; Self-destructive (Millon); The Lovable But Helpless Child; The Ugly, Unlovable Child; The Little Mother; The Bar Fighter (Greenberg)

Often comorbid with: depression, bipolar disorders, substance abuse, social anxiety, panic disorder, eating disorders, PTSD, ADHD, other PDs

Often confused with: depression, bipolar disorders, separation anxiety disorder, HPD, StPD, PPD, NPD, AsPD, DPD, non-disordered identity problems or in other disorders

Greenberg on BPD

Major issues

  • Continuous search for reparenting (love, nurturance) leads to clinging to other people and neglecting themselves
  • Want others to take on their responsibilities

Main goals

  • Find someone to give them love and nurturing
  • Avoid abandonment and engulfment

Difficult times

  • When they are required to self-activate*, structure their lives and act independently

Major defenses

  • Splitting, denial, clinging & distancing
  • Impulsivity as a distraction

Secret fears

  • That they are unlovable
  • If they self-activate and become a fully independent adult, they or their caregiver figure will “die or go crazy”

Contribution to the world

  • Bring passion and liveliness
  • “Their clinging is the glue that holds many families together”
  • Creativity

Interpersonal gestalt (The primary focus for the person with BPD during social interactions)

  • Cues that involved the potential to be loved and nurtured or abandoned and engulfed

Motto

  • “You do it for me; it’s too hard”

* Self activation is “the ability to identify and act on one’s true needs and desires and the ability to support oneself enough to stay motivated until one attains them” (i.e., taking care of yourself).

Subtypes

The Lovable But Helpless Child

  • Goes through life “feeling like a helpless child in the body of an adult”
  • Prioritises wants (fun, pleasure) over needs (adult responsibilities)
  • Wants someone else to step in and take over their responsibilities, so acts lovable and childlike
  • If they find that person, will eventually split on them and the relationship falls apart

The Ugly, Unlovable Child

  • Has “almost given up on being loved”, feels like “an abandoned and unwanted child"
  • “If you are going to reject them, they would like to get it over with quickly”
  • Shows their worst side first to test if “they dare show you more of themselves”
  • Often hostile and resistant

The Little Mother

  • Completely revolves around being the ‘mum friend’
  • Neglects themselves and their own wants and needs for other people
  • Always tired, wants someone to take care of them like they take care of others
  • Lacks assertiveness and boundaries

The Bar Fighter

  • Always angry, always looking for a fight
  • All ‘bad’ feelings (sadness, abandonment, fear, hurt, rejection, panic, rage) are processed & expressed as anger
  • Prone to substance abuse
  • Little to no awareness of their emotions and impact

Mnemonic: MISERY

M: Mother problems

  • Fails to separate fully from caregivers & tries to get approval and attention from them

I: Identity problems

  • Lacks an integrated self image which leads to splitting
  • Underdeveloped & fragmented sense of self

S: Splitting

  • Sees people (including themselves) as all-good or all-bad, preventing the negative from destroying the positive but leading to an incomplete picture

E: Engulfment and abandonment fears

  • “All intimacy has the potential to be threatening because it is hard […] to find a comfortable, interpersonal distance”
  • Fears engulfment (losing autonomy and becoming ‘engulfed’ by others) so distances themselves
  • Fears abandonment so they cling and demand (splits between withdrawing and clinging)

R: Rage

  • Tend to “experience themselves as having a core of inner rage that is boundless” but are passive because they “fear that if they did let themselves feel the full extent of their rage, they would go out of control forever”
  • Rage leads to splitting which often leads to self harm

Y: Yearning

  • Yearns for the “perfect other”, someone who will “give them unconditional love and acceptance; permission for separation; […] 24-hour devotion with nothing demanded in return”
  • Yearns for the “perfectly loving parental figure” so that they can finally have the love and acceptance they didn’t get in childhood

Borderline Personality Style vs Disorder

Style Disorder
Stable relationships, can see both the good and the bad in people at the same time. Intense and unstable relationships, where people are either all-good (idealised) or all-bad (devalued) with no in between.
Can be impulsive within the range of "culturally approved indulgence", but it doesn't cause damage to themselves or others. Impulsivity that is damaging to themselves and others, e.g. spending, sex, substance abuse, shoplifting, reckless driving, binge eating
Stable moods that don't dip too low or swing too high. Mood swings, with frequent depression, irritability, and anxiety.
Able to manage and tolerate anger. Unable to control anger, which is intense and more that the situation calls for.
Sense of connection to themself, their body, and the world. Often feels bored and empty, dissociated.
A cohesive, united sense of self that is consistent without being too flexible or not flexible enough. Fragmented and unstable sense of self, uncertainty about at least two of the following: self-image, sexual orientation and/or gender identity, long-term goals or career choice, type of friends desired, values and morals.
Able to realistically assess and manage feelings of loss. Imagined or actual abandonment provokes desperation and self-damaging behaviours.
May have suicidal ideation but doesn't act on it, or any other self-harming behaviours. Repeated suicidal and/or self-harming behaviours.
Able to manage stressful situations and stay present. Stress triggers psychosis and/or dissociation.

Psychosis in BPD

Psychosis in BPD is actually pretty common.

This information is from one study conducted in 2013 using DSM-III-R criteria, with a sample size of 362 people (290 of those with BPD).

All of the types of disturbed but non-psychotic thought studied were common.
  • This includes odd thinking, unusual perceptual experiences (UPEs), non-delusional paranoia, and depersonalisation and derealisation
  • 86% reported odd thinking, 76% reported UPEs, and 87% reported paranoia
  • (If you’re familiar with StPD, you’ll recognise that those are part of the StPD criteria - further evidence of the huge overlap of BPD & StPD)
  • This study suggests that splitting, especially on themselves, is a type of ideas of reference
Quasi-psychotic thought was common among borderline patients […] (57%).
  • This paper suggests that fears of abandonment is a type of quasi-psychotic thought
  • (Quasi-psychosis, in this paper, means psychosis that is limited, short-lived, and non-bizarre)
A significantly higher percentage of borderline patients than […] comparison subjects reported true-psychotic hallucinations (but not delusions) and any type of true-psychotic thought. [...] True-psychotic experiences […] are rare among our sample of borderline inpatients. At no time period, was the percentage of these patients reporting any true-psychotic thought (delusions and/or hallucinations) greater than 7%.
  • 7% is still a significant number
  • Delusions were more common than hallucinations (this was true for quasi-delusions too)
  • (True-psychosis in this paper means psychosis that is widespread (in thoughts or behaviour), long-term, and bizarre)

Resources & FAQs